Overview

For years, conspiracy theories have surrounded the Montauk area - from government projects to something deeper and more supernatural. Now, using files unearthed from the archives of the Suffolk County Police department, bear witness to the latest - and most shocking - incident in the history of the area.

Top Cast

Lauren Hodges

Susan

James McCaffrey

Roger

P

Phoenix List

Jeffrie

P

Phoenix List

Jeffrey

Kelly Deadmon

Jane

Terry Serpico

Jim

J

Joe Pospisil

911 Operator