Tamara Lynn Chambers

Dolores

Doug Walker

Nostalgia Critic

Malcolm Ray

Contestant #1

Brett Bonynge

Contestant #2

Robbie Allen

Bob

Alyssa Jackson

Barbara

Paul Rohan

Ben

Jimmy Melf

Reilly

Harry Locke IV

Julio

Jim Jarosz

Rolly the Fox/Practitioner

Heather Reusz

Atlantis Somerset

Nick La Banca

Nautical Nineties Narrator